There are all sorts of eye makeup removers on the market but the best one I’ve found is Vaseline. I learned this trick in high school from Seventeen Magazine and I’ve been using it ever since.
Why? Well, it’s easy and it doesn’t sting the eye. And it’s cheap. Some beauty experts tout Vaseline is actually good for the skin around the eyes. (I don’t really buy that — the tender skin around my eyes doesn’t seem better than average after years of Vaseline).